Gardeners will often talk about their favorite type of manure, and I myself am not immune from such opining ...but when you have numerous acres to cover the decision is often made by factors of cost and convenience. While it may be ideal to envision a farm that raises animals to generate manure for it’s vegetable fields, limited acreage and limited human energy make this a difficult proposition for vegetable farmers.
So purchasing chicken manure is the most common choice, as it’s high potency makes it cheaper to ship and easier to apply. It is also free of weed seed. And while I am using chicken manure, it does have it’s down sides. For one, it’s narrow carbon-nitrogen ratio means it contributes less to the building of soil organic matter. It is also the by-product of industrial chicken farming. You just don’t get mountains of chicken manure from raising pastured poultry.
Coastal Humboldt county has an abundance of dairies, so local cow manure seems like the natural choice. Cow manure isn’t as potent, which means you need to use more of it; and even still, it will take multiple applications before these slowly released nutrients create nutrient sufficiency. On the plus side, the shear bulk of organic matter you get from these higher application rates has its own benefits. Finding quantities of cow manure that is ready to use, however, can be difficult ...especially when you don’t have your own dump truck. I am lucky to have found a source for already composted manure that I can pay to have delivered to my farm. Unfortunately, this manure is also pretty weedy. As the piles sit composting, annual weeds grow on them and make seed, and the rancher I purchase from is not able to keep these down. I am trying to ameliorate this by purchasing fresher manure that I can allow to compost on site for next year’s use. The challenge with this is that is takes time (and extra space) to turn these piles for uniform decomposition. The piles do get one turning when they get dumped at my farm, and I’m hoping this (combined with the action of my manure spreader) is enough.

Fully-composted Cow Manure

1/2 Composted Cow Manure
I love the field I’m farming ...primarily for it’s town-accessible location, and also for the good drainage over most of the site. The soils are all loams, with some nearer to clay loams and others almost sandy loams with a bit of gravel. These changes reflect differing topographic positions across the site, as you move from an old floodplain down a small slope to an ancient river channel.
With regard to soil fertility, however, the place could use some help. Unlike most of the fields in the Arcata bottoms, this one doesn’t seem to have been limed much. The pH ranged from 5.3 to 5.6 before I started adding lime. The place has also been exporting hay (and nutrients) for many years, and the infrequent mowing did not favor legumes. A soil test (and crop growth) showed nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium levels ranging from medium to low across the three sampled zones, with calcium, sulfur, and boron being low throughout.
While there are organic amendments to address all of these shortcomings, cost is a limiting factor. I had to decide where to begin, knowing that I couldn’t afford a complete makeover all at once. The plan I came up with for a starting point was: 1 ton/acre of lime, 1/2 ton/acre of rock phosphate (mixed with a tiny amount of Fertibor Boron), 10 yards/acre of composted cow manure, and 1 ton/acre of chicken manure; to be combined with seasonal cover cropping. So far, the results have been good, but I’ll need to keep it up in order to bring fertility levels to where I need them to be. In the short term, higher levels of chicken manure are going to be the most economical way to get me through, but I’d like to move away from this as time goes on (find out why in the next posting). I’m definitely going to keep up the liming and I’d like to keep adding phosphate, but I’m not sure I can afford it.
My longer term plan involves putting two of my six annual-crop acres into a year-long cover crop, and rotating through these fields. This should really help reduce my input needs, while building soil O.M. and smothering weeds.
They are turning the dirt and hoping to be successful enough to turn a profit, and to become a valuable part of their communities as suppliers of organically grown food.
Peaceful Valley is giving them a head start by offering them special pricing as part of this Freshman Farmer program.
| Freshman: | |
| New Farms Coming Soon! | |
| Sophomores: | |
![]() | Daily Grace Farms Crescent City, CA |
![]() | Freestone Family Farm Vernal, UT |
![]() | Wise Moon Farm Redding, CA |
| Graduates: | |
![]() | Coyote House Farm Palermo, CA |
![]() | DeepSeeded Community Farm Arcata, CA |
![]() | Driftwood Farm Fort Bragg, CA |
![]() | EarthDance Farm St. Louis, MO |
![]() | Ellwood Canyon Farms Goleta, CA |
![]() | Four Frog Farm Penn Valley, CA |
![]() | Hand Sown Homegrown Heritage Farm Poulsbo, WA |
![]() | Home Plate Organic Farm Orleans, CA |
![]() | Honey in the Heart Farm Nevada City, CA |
![]() | Willow Springs Farm Penn Valley, CA |
| Coyote House Farm Palermo, CA |
| Daily Grace Farms Crescent City, CA |
| DeepSeeded Community Farm Arcata, CA |
| Driftwood Farm Fort Bragg, CA |
| EarthDance Farm St. Louis, MO |
| Ellwood Canyon Farms Goleta, CA |
| Four Frog Farm Penn Valley, CA |
| Freestone Family Farm Vernal, UT |
| Hand Sown Homegrown Heritage Farm Poulsbo, WA |
| Home Plate Organic Farm Orleans, CA |
| Honey in the Heart Farm Nevada City, CA |
| Willow Springs Farm Penn Valley, CA |
| Wise Moon Farm Redding, CA |