Organic Certification and my Chagrin

March 29th, 2009
Four Frog Farm | Blog

Hello,

My name is Andrew.  You may remember me from such rants as not agreeing, on principle, with organic certification and needing approval and validation by the government to sell “organic” food.  Is my produce any less “organic” because it doesn’t have the CCOF seal of approval.  What a bunch of balooney…at least that’s what I said.

As of Ferbruary 17thish, 2009, Four Frog Farm became a real organic farm, according to CCOF and our beloved government.  Even though our government may have its issues, it can sure as heck specify what an organic farm is and is not.  I love that I now share such hallowed ground with Earthbound and Grimmway.  We are, like, best buds. We’re doing lunch next week with some organic carrots and lettuce mix from Mexico.

So, we’re in the club!!! Yay for us!!! Yay for $950 spent with CCOF!!!  Yay for being overcharged on our inspection!!!  

Okay, I think I’m done with the sarcasm.  I’m actually interested to hear what other people have to say about being certified organic.  On one hand it protects the consumer. Example:  last year at our local farmers’ market, a grower from the valley would routinely say that their produce was organic (though not certified!!!) when asked by a customer.  For several reasons, I had some serious doubts that their produce was organic (or even their own produce!).  So, in that case, you can trust the certification (and what that certification means, I’ll leave up to you).

On the other hand it gives out government a level of control that makes me even more resentful and rebelious than I already am.  I mean, I have a hard time taking a certification from a government that says organic isn’t better than chemical ag, just different.  They are beholden (dems and republicans alike to be sure) to their constituents, who often times are the likes of ADM, Cargill and Monsanto.

Anyway, we are certified organic by CCOF…we just need to pay the whopping inspection fee.

Adios,

Bothered in Penn Valley

4 Responses to “Organic Certification and my Chagrin”

Drew Says:
Mar 30th, 2009 at 7:13 pm

Hey Andrew.  Was Becky your regional CCOF inspector?  The good news is that she is training an apprentice out in Oroville, so next year’s mileage expense should be smaller if she came out of Fairfield or somewhere like that.  Good luck!

Drew Says:
Mar 30th, 2009 at 7:46 pm

Awright, I read your post again.  Yes, our farm was organic before the inspectors came.  I also had much better plans for the money than giving it to someone to tell me something I already knew. 

And then my niece, holding her baby, said to me that she would like to eat organic but can’t afford it.  Instead of saying, “Oh.  And what is the poison discount these days?” I remembered why I am doing this. 

It ain’t the money and short hours, brother.  There is something wrong with our food system and we need to stand up and fix it by providing decentralized, clean food to a population that might be ready to hear the message.  And as important, we have to show them why it’s better.

We are going to have barriers because conventional ag is deeply invested.  They buy their own “organic” divisions and lobby to soften the rules to sell to our growing customer base (Imitation is the purest form of flattery).  So we farmers end up fighting for cleaner, tougher rules to differentiate ourselves and get our communities to ask the questions:  What is the difference?

That is when we will arrive.  When someone comes to our stand and says, “Okay, you’re CCOF certified.  Good start, I guess.  What else do you do?  Do you process non-organic products on your farm?  Are your chickens pastured, not just free range?  Do you make your compost or use stuff on the OMRI list?” and things like that.  Real questions about their food. 

Yeah, right now Safeway sells O Organics, and people buy them. Its a tiny step.  Next they will want to upgrade.  It is up to us to show them where to upgrade to.  Show them Beyond Organic.  We need to educate people on the practices we are passionate about that the megafarms won’t do.  There are enough people who will react to this and we will win enough business to thrive. But before we can get the customer who wants to know the difference between on-farm sustainability methods, we need to get them to see us as the better option.  Right now organic certification is an important, albeit imperfect, tool to that end.  Without it we are more expensive and have little to differentiate ourselves in the market in the product itself (Oh, besides quality and taste…)

When they come to your farm, see how you do it, understand your reasons, and tell their friends that they trust you, you will sell all your shares.  You’ll also gain ground for sustainable agriculture as you grow smarter people.

Andrew Says:
Mar 31st, 2009 at 9:53 am

Drew,

I appreciate your thoughts on certification.  I agree with you on many points.  In our system, the certification is that best thing we have right now.  I am thankful for the work that CCOF does to continually increase organic integrity and standards.  The USDA NOP is a juggernaut of sorts and seems slow to take progressive steps.  I am so thankful that people are demanding organic, even though they might not know exactly what it means.

holly dumont Says:
Apr 16th, 2009 at 6:18 am

Andrew,  We have been organic for 20 years.  Although we pay our annual fed government and state registration., we are not certified.  We already have too many government folks with their hands in our pockets.  (taxes, insurance, county ag inspection, farmers market fees, well tax, it just goes on and on.  I don’t think the USDA organic rules benefit anyone except certifiers,  who also lobbied for the bill.
We have always thought that conventional agriculture should be certified and inspected and those of us growing organic should get to skate!
We follow all the rules for organic and yes, you can say your organic if you don’t have more than $5000 worth of income. 

Farm on

Reply to this post

Your Name (required) Email, won't be published (required)

Please enter the word you see in the image below:



Three farms are starting from scratch.

They are turning the dirt and hoping to be successful enough to turn a profit, and to become a valuable part of their communities as suppliers of organically grown food.

Peaceful Valley is giving them a head start by offering them special pricing as part of this Freshman Farmer program.

The Farm Blogs

Freshman:
New Farms Coming Soon!
Sophomores:
Daily Grace Farms
Crescent City, CA
Freestone Family Farm
Vernal, UT
Wise Moon Farm
Redding, CA
Graduates:
Coyote House Farm
Palermo, CA
DeepSeeded Community Farm
Arcata, CA
Driftwood Farm
Fort Bragg, CA
EarthDance Farm
St. Louis, MO
Ellwood Canyon Farms
Goleta, CA
Four Frog Farm
Penn Valley, CA
Hand Sown Homegrown Heritage Farm
Poulsbo, WA
Home Plate Organic Farm
Orleans, CA
Honey in the Heart Farm
Nevada City, CA
Willow Springs Farm
Penn Valley, CA

Blog Topics

About the Farms

Coyote House Farm
Palermo, CA
Daily Grace Farms
Crescent City, CA
DeepSeeded Community Farm
Arcata, CA
Driftwood Farm
Fort Bragg, CA
EarthDance Farm
St. Louis, MO
Ellwood Canyon Farms
Goleta, CA
Four Frog Farm
Penn Valley, CA
Freestone Family Farm
Vernal, UT
Hand Sown Homegrown Heritage Farm
Poulsbo, WA
Home Plate Organic Farm
Orleans, CA
Honey in the Heart Farm
Nevada City, CA
Willow Springs Farm
Penn Valley, CA
Wise Moon Farm
Redding, CA

Tags

Archives

Stories From Peaceful Valley

Susan Morrison Co-Author of Garden UP May 17, 2012
GrowOrganic
Plant Support Options May 17, 2012
GrowOrganic
The best room and board for your backyard chickens May 10, 2012
Charlotte from Peaceful Valley
Raising Chickens May 9, 2012
GrowOrganic
How to Measure Water Pressure & Flow May 4, 2012
GrowOrganic
Water pressure and water flow issues for gardeners May 3, 2012
Charlotte from Peaceful Valley
Irrigation Maintenance April 26, 2012
GrowOrganic
How to maintain your drip irrigation system April 26, 2012
Charlotte from Peaceful Valley
Double Digging April 19, 2012
GrowOrganic

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

Meta

Username:
Password:
Remember me?
Entries RSS
Comments RSS